Thursday, 27 November 2014
The novel The Woman In White by Wilkie Collins is a classic,
cryptic, fiction indited in the 1860s. Judging on the book's denomination, i
was expecting a frighteningly eerie or thriller theme in the very beginning of
the novel. Instead, the novel is more of a peculiar love story. The plot is
that a man Walter Hartright meets a woman dressed in white and ascertained that
she escaped from a asylum to pass a message along to an inscrutable
baronet. Albeit Hartright avails her to elude without being caught and he
never expects to visually perceive her again, somehow he cannot forget about
her. In my opinion, Collins made the book very perplexing because he did not
make it clear what the characters were doing and why they were doing it. I
dislike the novel because it shows lack of suspense. nothing fascinating
occurred which made me lose interest immediately. however; Walter accumulates
information in the form of letters and journal ingresses about events
that the characters have witnessed unique way. Although Walter utilizes a
unique way to indite this novel, i still find it boring. i additionally feel
like this book requires patience considering the book is 500 pages long. I
believe the novel is only prosperous in giving inscrutable effect but it has
lack of suspense. Overall, I believe this novel is one of the boringest books i
have ever read. as i read more, i hope that the story will become more engaging
as i read further to discover incipient events.
The Woman in White is by Wilkie Collins,
published in 1860; it is a Victorian fiction novel. The setting of
the book is an asylum in London. When
I was reading this book, I was worried at first that the format would be confusing
and hard to get into. However, slowly as I started reading the novel I was
surprised how easily everything flowed and how quickly the story started. The
story is told in a unique format; it is told through a series of letters,
journal entries, and testimonies. The novel jumps right into the story
without a whole lot of long Victorian wordiness, which for me, was difficult to
understand since it is a different format of writing than I am usually use to
reading. The novel starts off with the introduction of one of
the main characters Walter Hartright. Hartright meets a young
woman dressed all in white late at night on a road back to London. He finds out
the woman has escaped from a nearby asylum to be able to pass a
message along to a mysterious baronet. Although Hartright helps her to escape
without being caught and he never expects to see her again, somehow he cannot
forget the ghostly figure. My prediction for the upcoming events in the novel
is that Walter Hartsight falls in love with this mysterious woman he
cannot find, and goes out searching for her. This is what I predict will happen
later on in the novel. In my opinion the tone of this book comes off as a
very mysterious vibe. I also feel like unless you've got the patience,
stamina, and taste for a mid-Victorian novel you wont enjoy this novel. You may
think The Woman In White is terribly overwrought and 500 pages too long. If you
like Victorian writing, you'll think this is a well-drawn, balanced novel with
characters to root for, characters to despise, a twisting plot that rolls up,
and narrated from many different points of view. I am still unsure if I like or
dislike this novel, I will have to read more in-depth to grasp a better
understanding on my opinion on it since I only read a couple of the first 20
pages so far. But so far this book comes off as quite interesting and very
mysterious which makes it more intense as I get deeper towards finishing the
end of the book
Response By:Stephanie wijenathan
ReplyDeleteIn my opinion i think, Deborah's first impression was pretty well done, she had good content of what she thought about the book and was its actually good for new readers who wanted good information about the novel to get to know what type of book they were getting into. I think for improvements she could have explained a little bit more about why her opinion was what it was on the book to give it more back up explanation. I also think she used big word that came up out of no where which didn't do justice to her first impression, i think this way because a person who hasn't even read the book and wants to know an opinion about it wouldn't understand to the best of there ability what the book was like if they didn't understand the words used in the first impression journal made. However i do like how she tried to elaborate on some parts and was honest with her opinion how she thought it was boring but maybe she might find it more engaging throughout the book, which was her truthful opinion. Also maybe if she edited it a few more times she could have made it a bit more better because i did find some grammatical errors while reading her first impression, but i do like how she talked about what type of book it was and what type of readers would enjoy it, that gives a better understand of the book in my opinion. overall i think she did a good job on her first impressions and if she used some of my feedback it may help her in her next tasks in this CPT.
journal response by: Deborah Anderson
ReplyDeleteStephanie, your first impressions journal very good. In the beginning you started your journal with a brief description of the book and a description of where the book takes place which is good for readers because they can predict what genre the book is. well done! Also, you made it clear that the text in the novel was not difficult to read and understand which is important to new readers. However; you stated "I am still unsure if I like or dislike this novel". In my opinion, this might make readers have difficulty deciding whether they want to read the novel or not. I like the way you expanded on your opinion. As I was reading your journal I did not find any errors in your grammar and you had very good transition words which made your text flow nicely. I think you were successful in explaining everything about the book in your first impression and you made predictions about the characters. overall, your journal is good and i hope my advice will help you improve as you progress